It is a necessary corollary from all that has been said already. If man be not free, he cannot be expected to keep laws, and should not be punished for breaking them. There can be no obligation to observe a law when it is not possible to keep it. This is the judgment of every normal mind. The judicial and punitive application of human legislation is outrageous if men are not responsible for their conduct. The theorists who talk of determinism never dream of applying their doctrine in practice.Again consciousness affords sufficient proof for every normal man. We are not only conscious before acting that there are various courses open to us, but we are conscious that we may desist from a course of action already adopted, and after acting, are conscious of self-approbation or self-reproach, realizing that we were not compelled to act that way.Finally, the possession of reason or intelligence cannot be without freedom of will. Granted a reasoning faculty which can apprehend finite things under different aspects, freewill follows. For example, the acquiring of another man’s money may be considered as involving the moral evil of obtaining it by theft, or as yielding one’s own goods in exchange for the sake of possessing cash. The object itself allows a man to concentrate upon one aspect or the other, proposing motives to himself for a good or an evil choice.
Radio Replies Volume 1 by Rev. Dr. Leslie Rumble MSC and Rev. Charles Mortimer Carty
🙏 PayPal Donation Appreciated
Related Posts:
- Will you prove the reliability of the Gospels according to the five requirements outlined by yourself to a previous inquirer?
- Good Works - The Catholic Church has the Answer
- What indications have you that the soul is immortal?
- But the moral theology of your Church is so dreadfully intolerant. If I follow apathetically the laws of that Church I might as well never have been endowed with freewill.
- What is this evidence for God's existence, apart from the Bible?
- I have studied Christianity and it is my honest opinion that it is not true. Yet you tell me that I am to believe that it is true!
- Birth Control - The Catholic Church has the Answer
- Did not Pope Gregory VII originate it in the 11th century?
- Even granting freedom, man is not entirely free, but only within certain limits.
- Man has not got a soul—he is a soul Genesis II., 7, says that man became a living soul
- Biblical Reasons Why Catholics Make Use of Images
- This sin business worries me. Is it possible that mortal man can sin against Almighty God? I can see that he can sin against his fellow mortal men.
- Which is the lesser of two evils—to bring undernourished children into the world for whom you cannot provide, or to practice contraception?
- The Church of England is Catholic because she is sending missionaries throughout the whole world as far as possible.
- Christ said that he who believes "cometh not into judgment, but is passed from death to life." Jn. V., 24.
- The Bible tells us to prove all things. I. Thess. V., 21. The Catholic Church demands that her adherents prove nothing, accepting all on her authority, and without question.
- The Laws of Nature and Their Divine Origin
- Why does the Catholic Church forbid cremation?
- How do you prove the existence of such a state?
- If God did not give me sufficient intelligence to be able to believe, surely no blame attaches to me?