Understanding Predestination: Catholicism vs Calvinism?

Historical Background

Brief Answer:

• The concept of predestination has roots in early Christian theology, notably with St. Augustine.
• Augustine’s writings emphasized God’s sovereignty and grace in salvation.
• The Protestant Reformation, particularly John Calvin, significantly shaped the debate.
• Calvin’s interpretation led to the doctrine of “double predestination.”
• The Catholic Church responded by clarifying its own teachings at the Council of Trent.
• This response affirms both God’s grace and human free will.

Detailed Answer:

The theological concept of predestination finds its early significant expression in the writings of St. Augustine of Hippo (354-430 AD). Grappling with questions of grace, free will, and divine sovereignty, Augustine emphasized that salvation is entirely a gift of God’s grace, unearned by human merit. He argued that God foreknows who will be saved and grants them the grace to persevere.

However, Augustine’s complex and evolving thought on predestination has been interpreted in various ways. Some scholars emphasize his insistence on God’s absolute sovereignty, while others highlight his later emphasis on the importance of human cooperation with grace. This ambiguity laid the groundwork for later debates.

The Protestant Reformation in the 16th century, particularly the theology of John Calvin (1509-1564), brought the issue of predestination to the forefront. Calvin, drawing on certain aspects of Augustine’s thought, developed a more rigid and deterministic view. His Institutes of the Christian Religion became a foundational text for Reformed theology.

Calvin’s doctrine of “double predestination” asserts that God, from eternity, has unconditionally elected some individuals for salvation (the elect) and reprobated others to damnation (the reprobate). This election is based solely on God’s sovereign will, not on any foreseen merit or faith in the individuals.

The Catholic Church, in response to the challenges posed by the Reformation, addressed the issue of predestination at the Council of Trent (1545-1563). The Council’s decrees sought to clarify the Church’s teaching, affirming both the primacy of God’s grace and the reality of human free will.

The Council of Trent condemned the notion that humans are purely passive in salvation or that God predestines anyone to hell without their free choice. It emphasized that while salvation is initiated by God’s grace, human beings must cooperate with that grace through faith and good works.

Scriptural Background

Brief Answer:

• Scripture presents a complex picture of God’s sovereignty and human responsibility.
• Passages like Romans 8:29-30 speak of God’s foreknowledge and predestination.
• Other texts, like 1 Timothy 2:4, emphasize God’s desire for all to be saved.
• “For those whom he foreknew he also predestined to be conformed to the image of his Son, in order that he might be the firstborn within a large family. And those whom he predestined he also called; and those whom he called he also justified; and those whom he justified he also glorified.” (Romans 8:29-30).
• Catholic interpretation seeks to harmonize these seemingly contradictory themes.
• This is done by affirming both divine initiative and human response.

Detailed Answer:

The Bible contains passages that, taken in isolation, could seem to support either a Calvinistic or a Catholic view of predestination. The key lies in interpreting these passages within the broader context of Scripture and Sacred Tradition.

Passages like Romans 8:29-30, often cited by Calvinists, speak of God’s foreknowledge and predestination: “For those whom he foreknew he also predestined to be conformed to the image of his Son, in order that he might be the firstborn within a large family. And those whom he predestined he also called; and those whom he called he also justified; and those whom he justified he also glorified.” This passage highlights God’s initiative in salvation.

However, other scriptural texts emphasize God’s universal salvific will. 1 Timothy 2:4 states that God “desires all people to be saved and to come to the knowledge of the truth.” This verse, and others like it, suggests that God’s desire is not limited to a select few. Ezekiel 33:11, God says “As I live, says the Lord God, I have no pleasure in the death of the wicked, but that the wicked turn from his way and live;“.

Jesus’ parables, such as the parable of the Prodigal Son (Luke 15:11-32), illustrate God’s mercy and willingness to welcome back even those who have strayed. The parable of the sower as told by Jesus in the Gospel of Matthew, illustrates this beautifully: “Behold, a sower went forth to sow… Some seeds fell upon good ground, and brought forth fruit” (Matthew 13:3,8). These stories emphasize the importance of human response and repentance.

The Gospels consistently portray Jesus as calling individuals to follow him, to repent of their sins, and to believe in the Gospel. This call implies a capacity for free response, a choice to accept or reject God’s offer of salvation. “For God so loved the world, as to give his only begotten Son; that whosoever believeth in him, may not perish, but may have life everlasting.” (John 3:16).

Catholic interpretation seeks to harmonize these seemingly contradictory themes by affirming both God’s sovereignty and human freedom. God’s foreknowledge does not negate human free will; rather, God knows how each person will freely respond to his grace.

Catholic Answers

Brief Answer:

• The Catholic Church teaches that God predestines no one to hell. (CCC 1037)
• God desires the salvation of all people. (1 Timothy 2:4)
• Salvation is a free gift of God’s grace, offered to all.
• Humans must cooperate with God’s grace through faith and good works.
• God’s foreknowledge does not violate human free will.
• The Church rejects “double predestination,” the idea that God predetermines some for damnation.

Detailed Answer:

The Catholic Church firmly rejects the Calvinistic notion of “double predestination.” The Catechism of the Catholic Church states unequivocally: “God predestines no one to go to hell; for this, a willful turning away from God (a mortal sin) is necessary, and persistence in it until the end” (CCC 1037). This clarifies that damnation is the result of a person’s free and persistent rejection of God’s grace.

The Church affirms that God desires the salvation of all people. This is rooted in Scripture, as seen in 1 Timothy 2:4: “God our Savior… desires all people to be saved and to come to the knowledge of the truth.” This universal salvific will of God is a cornerstone of Catholic teaching.

Salvation is understood as a free gift of God’s grace, initiated by God and offered to all. However, this gift requires a response. Humans are not passive recipients; they must actively cooperate with God’s grace through faith and good works. The Council of Trent emphasized this cooperation, stating that while justification is by grace alone, it is not without human participation.

The Catholic understanding of predestination emphasizes the interplay between divine grace and human free will. God’s grace enables and empowers our free will, but it does not override it. We are free to accept or reject God’s offer of salvation. The Catechism states, “To God, all moments of time are present in their immediacy. When therefore he establishes his eternal plan of ‘predestination’, he includes in it each person’s free response to his grace” (CCC 600).

God’s foreknowledge, his knowledge of all events past, present, and future, is often a point of contention in discussions of predestination. The Catholic Church teaches that God’s foreknowledge does not violate human free will. God knows how each person will freely choose, but his knowledge does not cause that choice.

The mystery of predestination, ultimately, remains a profound theological truth that cannot be fully grasped by human reason. The Catholic Church approaches this mystery with a balance of reverence for God’s sovereignty and respect for human freedom, emphasizing the love and mercy of God who desires the salvation of all.

🙏 Support Catholic Answers – Donate via PayPal Now!

• donate monthly
• donate once only

Select a Donation Option (USD)

$10.00 (p/m) $50.00 (p/m) $100.00 (p/m) Other (p/m)

Enter Donation Amount (USD)