Which Bible Verses Challenge Protestant Beliefs?

The Church and Its Foundation

Brief Answer

• Matthew 16:18 establishes Peter as the rock on which Christ builds His Church.
• The Church’s authority predates the finalized canon of Scripture.
• The Council of Rome (382 A.D.) declared the full canon of the Bible.
• Matthew 18:17 highlights the Church’s role in resolving disputes.
• 1 Timothy 3:15 calls the Church “the pillar and ground of the truth.”
• The Church’s continuity counters claims of its corruption or failure.

Detailed Answer

The foundation of the Church as established by Christ is clearly articulated in Matthew 16:18, where Jesus states: “And I say to thee: That thou art Peter; and upon this rock I will build my church, and the gates of hell shall not prevail against it.” This statement asserts Peter’s primacy in the Church’s establishment and its divine protection from ultimate destruction. The passage challenges Protestant interpretations that deny the significance of Peter’s role or attempt to separate Christ’s Church from its historical continuity.

The early Church functioned before the New Testament was fully compiled and recognized, demonstrating that ecclesiastical authority preceded the canon. The Council of Rome in 382 A.D. confirmed the canon, including the 73 books used by the Catholic Church today. This fact refutes the notion that Scripture alone (sola scriptura) was the guiding principle from the beginning.

The authority of the Church is further supported by Matthew 18:17, which instructs believers to “tell the church” when resolving disputes, implying an authoritative body capable of binding decisions. This contradicts the idea that each believer can interpret Scripture independently without a guiding authority.

In 1 Timothy 3:15, St. Paul refers to the Church as “the pillar and ground of the truth,” emphasizing that the Church itself upholds divine truth rather than Scripture alone. This passage presents a problem for Protestant views that reject the necessity of a visible, authoritative Church.

Additionally, historical claims that the Church became corrupt beyond recognition contradict Christ’s promise in Matthew 16:18. If the Church had truly fallen into apostasy, then Christ’s assurance that the gates of hell would not prevail would be false, which is impossible.

Thus, biblical and historical evidence affirm the Catholic Church’s foundational role, its authority, and its continued existence under Christ’s divine protection.

The Eucharist: The Body and Blood of Christ

Brief Answer

• John 6:54 commands the faithful to eat Christ’s flesh and drink His blood.
• The Jews in John 6:52 struggled with the literal meaning of Jesus’ words.
• Jesus reinforces the necessity of consuming His body in John 6:55.
• Luke 22:19 institutes the Eucharist at the Last Supper.
• St. Paul warns against unworthy reception in 1 Corinthians 11:27.
• These passages support the Real Presence, not a symbolic interpretation.

Detailed Answer

The teaching of the Eucharist as Christ’s true Body and Blood is one of the most challenging doctrines for many Protestants. In John 6:54, Jesus states: “Except you eat the flesh of the Son of man, and drink his blood, you shall not have life in you.” The language is explicit—eating His flesh and drinking His blood is a requirement for eternal life.

Many Protestant interpretations attempt to reduce this to a symbolic statement, but the reaction of the Jews in John 6:52 suggests otherwise: “The Jews therefore strove among themselves, saying: How can this man give us his flesh to eat?” Jesus did not correct their literal understanding; instead, He reinforced it in John 6:55, saying, “For my flesh is meat indeed: and my blood is drink indeed.” This intensifies the claim rather than softening it.

The institution of the Eucharist is recorded in Luke 22:19, where Jesus, at the Last Supper, states: “This is my body, which is given for you. Do this in memory of me.” The Greek word used for “is” (estin) signifies identity, not symbolism.

St. Paul further emphasizes this reality in 1 Corinthians 11:27, warning that those who receive unworthily are “guilty of the body and of the blood of the Lord.” This would make little sense if the Eucharist were purely symbolic; one cannot be guilty of the Lord’s Body and Blood if the elements were merely bread and wine.

Given these passages, the Catholic doctrine of the Real Presence is rooted in Scripture and was the belief of the early Church. Attempts to reduce the Eucharist to a symbolic act contradict the plain meaning of the biblical text.

Faith and Works: A Harmonious Relationship

Brief Answer

• James 2:20 states, “Faith without works is dead.”
• James 2:24 affirms justification by works and not by faith alone.
• Galatians 2:16 speaks of justification through faith but does not deny works.
• Matthew 23:3 distinguishes between genuine and hypocritical works.
• St. Paul frequently uses “charity” as essential for salvation.
• Revelation 14:13 affirms that works follow the righteous after death.

Detailed Answer

The Protestant doctrine of justification by faith alone (sola fide) faces a serious challenge from James 2:20: “But wilt thou know, O vain man, that faith without works is dead?” The passage does not merely suggest that works are a natural fruit of faith but explicitly states that faith alone, without works, is lifeless.

This point is reinforced in James 2:24: “Do you see that by works a man is justified, and not by faith only?” This verse contradicts the claim that justification is by faith alone and presents an integrated view where faith and works cooperate in salvation.

Protestants often cite Galatians 2:16, where St. Paul writes that “a man is not justified by the works of the law, but by the faith of Jesus Christ.” However, Paul is addressing the Jewish law (Torah), not the good works that accompany faith. This distinction is crucial to understanding that Paul and James are not in contradiction.

In Matthew 23:3, Jesus criticizes the Pharisees for their hypocrisy, not for performing good works. He states: “All things therefore whatsoever they shall say to you, observe and do: but according to their works do ye not.” This indicates that works themselves are not the issue; rather, insincerity is.

Furthermore, St. Paul speaks of “charity” (agape) as essential in 1 Corinthians 13:2: “And if I should have all faith, so that I could remove mountains, and have not charity, I am nothing.” Here, even a faith capable of miracles is insufficient without love expressed in action.

Lastly, Revelation 14:13 states: “Blessed are the dead who die in the Lord. From henceforth now, saith the Spirit, that they may rest from their labors; for their works follow them.” This verse indicates that works have lasting significance beyond earthly life.

These passages present an inseparable relationship between faith and works, aligning with Catholic teaching rather than the Protestant doctrine of faith alone.

Support Catholic Answers – Donate via PayPal Now!

• donate monthly
• donate once only

Select a Donation Option (USD)

$10.00 (p/m) $50.00 (p/m) $100.00 (p/m) Other (p/m)

Enter Donation Amount (USD)